I had dinner with an old friend last night, and we started discussing school vouchers. His contention is that anyone who favors vouchers wants to keep poor people poor and rich people rich by making it so those poor people can't get a good education. Ridiculous! I favor vouchers, and want nothing of the sort. In fact, I believe an anti-voucher stance does far more to keep poor people down. Think about the situation now, if you are a poor person.
You live in a low-income area, your parents can't afford to move. Your public school sucks, it is racked by violence daily, most of the students don't care, and many of the teachers have resigned themselves to just getting their jobs done with a minimum of hassle. You are stuck, and there's nothing you can do. On the other hand, some kid a few miles away lives in a high-income area and has a good public school. Sure, his parents could afford a private school, but why should they bother, he's already getting a good education in a fairly safe environment.
What happens when you add vouchers to the mix? The poor kid has a choice! He can't afford transportation to the nicer area of town, but now he can afford to go the new private school ion his area that caters to poor kids who want a good education, and who have parents that give a damn. The rich kid is going to stay at his public school, because he has no need to leave. Sure, he could take his voucher and go to a private school, but there's no need, he won't get any better of an education.
What group am I not mentioning? The people at the low income public school that are not proactive. And you know what? Too damn bad, if they don't want to go to better school, well at least they have option. Right now they have no choice. Our current educational system only serves to keep people where they are. Vouchers give choice.
And lest we forget, history has shown again and again that competition leads to improvements. When public schools have to compete with private schools for money, they will have to either improve or shut down. And the private schools, even the ones in low-income areas, will have to do a good job, because their students are the ones that made the choice to better themselves and they will find a different school to take their vouchers to if the first one seems like they are just trying to take people's money and not give a good education.
Don't give me the canard about how all the private schools will end up teaching creationism and such. If there were that many evangelicals going around, wouldn't Pat Buchanan have won the Presidency?